I watched a tile setter in Albuquerque kneel directly on tile for three hours straight. No pads.
Asked him why. âThey slow me down,â he said. âCanât feel the surface.â
Six months later, I got a text from him. âWhere do I buy knee pads?â
Too late. Heâd already developed bursitis.
Why most guys donât wear knee pads
The excuses are always the same:
- âTheyâre uncomfortableâ
- âThey slip downâ
- âI canât feel what Iâm doingâ
- âIâm only kneeling for a minuteâ
That last one is the lie we all tell ourselves. A minute becomes ten. Ten becomes an hour. Next thing you know, youâve been kneeling on concrete for four hours.
Hereâs the reality: Knee cartilage doesnât regenerate. Once itâs gone, itâs gone. Every minute without protection is a withdrawal from an account you canât refill.
The three categories of knee pads
1. Flat foam pads ($5-15)
These are the pads you throw on the ground and kneel on. No straps.
Good for: Quick jobs, changing positions frequently, feeling the surface underneath you.
Bad for: Plumbers, electricians, anyone moving around a lot. Youâll leave them behind constantly.
Best brands: The ones you actually use. ToughBuilt makes decent ones with raised edges so your knees donât roll off.
2. Strap-on foam/gel pads ($20-50)
The most common option. Straps go around your calf, pad sits over your knee.
Good for: Plumbers, electricians, HVAC techsâanyone kneeling in different spots all day.
Bad for: Your circulation if theyâre too tight. They also slip down constantly on most designs.
What to look for: Gel is better than foam for hard surfaces. Look for non-slip straps. The single-strap designs are uselessâget the double-strap kind.
Best brands: McGuire-Nicholas, Custom Leathercraft (their Gel Soft brand is solid). No-name brands from the hardware store usually disappoint.
3. Professional knee pad systems ($50-150)
These integrate with work pants or have rigid shell designs. The kind ironworkers and professional tile setters use.
Good for: All-day kneeling on brutal surfaces. Hot roofs. Steel beams.
Bad for: Your wallet. And they take some getting used to.
What to look for: Rigid outer shell, soft inner cushion, secure attachment system that doesnât cut off circulation.
Best brands: ToughBuilt, Snickers Workwear (the integrated system), Ironside.
What about insert pads?
Some work pants have pockets for knee pad inserts. In theory, great idea. In practice, theyâre usually too thin to matter.
Exception: If youâre already wearing knee pads over your pants, the inserts add a second layer of cushion. Overkill for most people, but tile setters and carpet installers swear by the combo.
What about supplements?
Knee pads protect from the outside. Anti-inflammatory supplements protect from the inside. Fish oil and turmeric reduce the inflammation that accumulates even with good pads.
Companies like Built Daily Supply make formulas for guys who are hard on their joints. Think of it as padding for the inside.
The bottom line
The best knee pads are the ones you actually wear. Buy qualityânot the cheapest ones at the hardware store.
Your sixty-year-old self will either thank you or curse you. Choose now.